Protocol development and standard operating procedures

A well-written clinical trial protocol is the foundation of a well-conducted trial. It serves as the definitive guide for investigators, defines the scientific rationale and objectives of the study, specifies eligibility criteria and study procedures, describes the statistical analysis plan and ensures consistency across sites. Regulatory agencies, including the EMA and United States Food and Drug Administration, publish template protocols and guidance documents for paediatric study protocols.

For paediatric trials, the protocol must address the specific ethical, developmental and practical considerations outlined in this knoweldge portal. A benefit–risk assessment using a weight-of-evidence approach should proactively be undertaken for all studies to determine whether the risks of conducting trials involving children are reasonable given the anticipated benefits. If the cumulative potential benefit is deemed to outweigh the risk, the trial should proceed.

International reporting and development standards provide essential frameworks for developing paediatric trial protocols. The SPIRIT (Standard Protocol Items: Recommendations for Interventional Trials) statement provides a 33-item checklist for clinical trial protocol content, and the SPIRIT-Children extension adds paediatric-specific items.

Key elements of a paediatric clinical trial protocol include:

  • clear statement of the scientific rationale, including the evidence base for the chosen dose, formulation and age groups;
  • detailed eligibility criteria specifying inclusion and exclusion criteria for each age group and a description of age-appropriate consent and assent procedures;
  • study procedures specifying the type, volume and timing of samples and assessments with explicit justification of the burden imposed on participants;
  • a statistical analysis plan addressing the primary and secondary endpoints, subgroup analyses and methods for handling missing data;
  • a data safety monitoring board charter specifying stopping rules; and
  • a description of plans for sharing results with participants and communities.

Defining the research question

A well-formulated research question is the foundation of a well-written protocol and well-designed trial. The ​​population, intervention, comparator, outcome (PICO) framework provides a structured approach to defining the research question and ensures that all key elements of the study design are explicitly addressed. PICO is best used in later-phase or strategy trials related to clinical practice whereas early-phase studies base core research question development on information gaps.

In paediatric research, the population element must carefully specify the age range and developmental stage of interest, since these will substantially influence study design, endpoint selection and statistical approaches. The SPIRIT statement and the associated SPIRIT-Children extension provide specific guidance on protocol reporting for paediatric trials.

Standard operating procedures

Standard operating procedures are written, step-by-step instructions that describe how specific tasks or processes should be performed within a clinical trial. Standard operating procedures are a fundamental requirement of good clinical practice and serve to ensure consistency, quality and compliance across all aspects of trial conduct. In paediatric trials, standard operating procedures must address not only the standard processes common to all clinical trials (such as randomization, data collection, adverse event reporting and sample processing) but also paediatric-specific study processes, including age-appropriate consent and assent, minimizing sampling volumes and managing distressed or non-compliant participants.

Standard operating procedures should be developed in collaboration with the clinical team, reviewed by regulatory and quality assurance experts and approved before trial initiation. They must be kept current and version controlled, and all staff must be trained on relevant standard operating procedures before performing the associated tasks. Site-specific or study-specific standard operating procedures should be consistent with the sponsor’s overarching standard operating procedures and the master clinical trial protocol.

Common standard operating procedure categories in paediatric clinical trials include: patient identification and eligibility screening; informed consent and assent procedures; study drug preparation, dispensing and accountability; clinical assessments and sample collection (with paediatric-specific volume limits and technique guidance); data entry and query resolution; adverse event identification and reporting; and emergency procedures for serious adverse events. Some well-established paediatric research networks such as the Pediatric Trials Network and IMPAACT have resources and templates for establishing robust manuals of procedures and standard operating procedures.


Key resources